Friday, August 14, 2015

Fwd: [nashimbyarok-WIG] Outrageous administrative detention-מעצר מינהלי שערורייתי and my comments


The facts have still to surface but my gut feeling is that there is a witch hunt against Jewish Settlers in order to portray them as "Jewish Terrorists".  Even when no one is actually convicted, the process itself libels and discredits the Settler communities in Judea and Samaria and makes it much easier in the future to destroy their homes and communities. It is was these psychological weapons used in the Gush Katif Expulsion that eventually enabled the operation to be successful.

Why the Government of Israel, sanctioned by a right wing gov't, is engaging in such acts of hostility against the Settlers is surprising and very disturbing!  Obviously there are pressures to which I am not privy to but surely, apologies or condemnations on behalf of the Settler community for acts that are not verifiable as being committed by Settlers is extremely damaging since it serves to further strengthen the idea that indeed there exists "Jewish Terrorists" within the Torah observant Settler community.

Let me clarify that the most right wing Settler, even if they quote the Torah on portions that seem to be incitement towards committing acts of violence are not different than speaking about "Ayin Tachath Ayin", Eye for an Eye.  Settlers with a Torah education that is based on Torah Shebichtav and Torah Shebaal Peh, the written and oral law,  understand that one needs a Rabbinical Court to implement the Burning of Idolatrous places of worship.  It is never advocated as an option for  individuals. It first must be determined by a Rabbinical Court like a Sanhedrin whether or not the Place of Worship is indeed Idolatrous.  There is a legal process before any actual military action is actualized according to the Torah. Yes it is conceivable that if a Sanhedrin  determines that a Place of Worship that promotes Child Sacrifice is idol worship (like sacrificing to the Molech) it might warrant it's destruction. Let me add that we have yet to establish a working Sanhedrin and that is one of the fears perhaps of those accusing the settlers...  

To accuse the Settlers of Price Tag Revenge is probably the work of implanted provocateurs of those who wish to discredit the Settlers. IF indeed they will find someone guilty of such a crime it would  probably be someone who do not have a strong Torah upbringing such as the Soccar fan thugs. While individuals might have their own private opinion of what constitute Idol worship or worthy of burning according to Torah, just like individuals might carry opinions as per whether someone like OJ Simpson was guilty and worthy of a death sentence, are according to the American  Constitution allowed to be free to have such opinions and even voice them. However, they are not allowed to in any way actualize them or engage in any violent way that will take the law into their own hands. 

If one wishes to accuse another of violence in order to discredit them without any evidence, taking kids into Administrative Detention is the only way.  

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: <>
Date: Fri, Aug 14, 2015 at 10:34 AM
Subject: [nashimbyarok-WIG] Outrageous administrative detention-מעצר מינהלי שערורייתי



חברים יקרים

אסור לנו לשתוק על המעצרים המינהליים השערוריתיים של שלושת היהודים  שנזרקו לכלא לחצי שנה, ללא כתב אישום.

מצורף בזה מכתבו של ח"כ בצלאל סמוטריץ הנותן הסבר ורקע לדברים.

הציבור מתבקש  ליצור קשר עם נבחרי הציבור בממשלה ובכנסת ולהבהיר להם חד-משמעית את התנגדותוו למעצרים המינהליים האלו.


לרשימת השרים וחברי הכנסת:


שבת שלום

יהודית קצובר ונדיה מטר





Dear Friends


We cannot stay quiet as 3 Jews have been put in administrative detention for half a year without any accusation against them

We call upon all to call the ministers and Knesset members and pass on a strong message of opposition to this scandal

Below is the translation of MK Bezalel Smotrich's letter.that explains what is happening

Here is a link to Michael Freund's article:Administrative detention and the assault on civil liberties

Government offices:

Knesset Members:

Shabbat shalom


Yehudit Katsover and Nadia Matar




The Knesset

MK Bezalel Smotrich

                                                                                                                        27 Menahem Av 5775

                                                                                                                        12 August 2015



Justice Minister

MK Ayelet Shaked


Defense Minister

MK Moshe Ya'alon


Minister of Internal Security

MK Gilad Erdan


Attorney General

Atty. Yehuda Weinstein



Distinguished Sirs and Madam,


Subject: The security services' lack of restraint in the manner that they deal with crime in Judea and Samaria


Unfortunately it seems that in recent days the Israel Police and General Security Services have lost all restraint in an attempt, which is important of itself, to locate the perpetrators of the severe incident in Kfar Duma.


The public noise, not to say, call for attack, and the resounding professional failure of the enforcement authorities until now in the prevention of such crimes and the identification of those who have carried them out, has deteriorated into what seems like actual hysteria, to the extent of a loss of control and the crossing of red lines that is difficult to accept in a democratic state of law.


Here are just a few examples of this hysterical and non-professional behavior:

1.       In recent days the Israel Police has gone to many heads of security in communities of Benyamin and demanded, without a warrant, to take recordings from all of the security cameras in the communities. Thus, across the board, resulting in a great intrusion of privacy and lack of respect to the residents of the communities in general, whose every step in recent days, no matter how personal or intimate, is exposed. It is inconceivable thus to harm the rights of so many people in so sweeping an action, in order to find a few perpetrators.

2.       Sunday, before sunrise, the police force descended upon the homes of seven families in the community of Adei Ad, awakened them and carried out a brutal search and ultimately, two people were arrested – one, a resident of Hevron who was required to attend an investigation and did not appear, and the other is a resident of the area and a member of the emergency unit of the community, and while a search was carried out in his house, an illegally owned bullet-proof vest was found… (the weapon that was found in his possession was legally owned). What is this if not hysteria?! What good does it do for the children of the seven families, after their traumatic meeting with the police, who will hate policemen for the rest of their lives?! What dangerous wanted criminals did they have to arrest there in such haste that justified waking up the children of a family before sunrise and causing them such a trauma as this search?!

3.       The outrageous administrative detentions, lacking specific connection to the incident at Duma (for example – the family of Eviatar Slonim told me that he was actually staying with his family on vacation when the incident occurred). About such things it is said, "Since the destroyer has the authority to destroy, he does not distinguish between the righteous and the sinner". Administrative detentions are a necessary evil to be used sparingly and when there is no other option. It is difficult to free ourselves of the feeling that the present wave of arrests is intended to compensate for past failures in investigating similar incidents and to appease impassioned public opinion. Have administrative detentions ever been used against organized crime in the State of Israel?! How is it that this tool is reserved only for the residents of Judea and Samaria?!

The three examples described above teach us about what seems like hysterical, unprofessional and unethical behavior, that serves no purpose other than to "check off" something on a list and to indulge the public and media hunger to see the system "do something". This behavior does great harm to the residents' rights and harms the public's faith in the law enforcement agencies no less.


I wish to take this opportunity to entirely reject any possible comparison that anyone might try to make in recent days between the treatment of Arab terror and the tools at the security system's disposal to deal with it and the treatment of very severe (!) actions that Jews have done against Arabs (assuming that it is Jews who did it).


The most common way to deal with crime and criminals in a democratic state is according to a criminal process and procedure, the balance between the need to defend society, to bring offenders to trial and to bring them to justice, and the need to maintain the rest of society's values, which, in general, are the rights of suspects and the accused within the framework of the process.


In the reality of battling against an enemy there is sometimes the necessity to use tools that are not normally used, among them the death sentence, demolition of houses as a deterrent to such deeds in the future, administrative detentions and so forth. We do not allow ourselves, and rightly so, to do this when faced with other severe social and criminal phenomena in society, including organized crime, which exacts a high price in blood, quite literally, and still does not justify the use of extra-ordinary tools for ordinary crime.


We are not engaged in a war against Jews! Crime is crime and it is the duty of law enforcement agencies to eradicate it. However, crime is not terror and crime perpetrated by citizens of a state does not make them enemies and does not justify acting outside the norm, as we must do in a war against enemies.


The various belligerent calls of "Jewish terror" and the intentions to give law enforcement agencies the tools at their disposal in the war against terror as well as against perpetrators who are citizens of the state, are populist and superficial and reflect an inability to make even a minimal distinction between complex situations. Your role as those responsible for the law enforcement agencies is to be able to deal with this complexity and navigate carefully between the delicate boundaries and this should dictate your policy.


Law enforcement agencies must display more professionalism and apparently also work harder in order to cope successfully with those few residents of the communities of Judea and Samaria who are suspected of criminal activity, but they must not be allowed to excuse a lack of professionalism and a lack of success by applying drastic tools from another world, including a grave blow to human rights, often regarding all the residents of Judea and Samaria (for example, the severe demand to take the recorded video from all of the security cameras in the communities of Binyamin).


As someone who has trust in the law enforcement agencies, I call on you not to be drawn into cheap and inflammatory populism and urgently to impose the necessary restraints on the law enforcement agencies.


Former president of the Supreme Court, Prof. Aharon Barak, often says that democracy is required to fight with one hand tied behind its back. If these words are correct in the Arab enemy's murderous war against terror, they are ten times as correct in dealing with brothers.


It is important to note, not incidentally, that regarding the incident in Duma, nothing has yet been proven to indicate that Jews are behind it. To the best of my knowledge, internal-Arab lines of inquiry, touching on internal conflicts between residents of the village, are also being investigated.


MK Bezalel Smotrich




You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google
Groups "nashimbyarok" group. This group is owned and operated by Women In Green For Israel's Tomorrow.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
Visit our website at
‏קיבלת את ההודעה הזו מפני שאתה רשום לקבוצה 'nashimbyarok' של קבוצות Google.
כדי לבטל את הרישום לקבוצה הזו ולהפסיק לקבל ממנה דוא"ל, שלח אימייל אל
לאפשרויות נוספות, בקר ב-


Robin Ticker

Activist emails sent to my list  are L'Ilui Nishmat Yisrael ben David Aryeh ob"m (Izzy - Kaplan) and Howard Chaim Grief great activists and lovers of Eretz Yisroel, Am Yisroel and the Torah. Yehi Zichronum Baruch.  May their memories serve as a blessing. 

Most of these emails are posted on 

Personal emails to individuals will not be posted to my blog. 
Post a Comment