Friday, February 05, 2016

Tzedek Tzedek Tirdof. Shabak tortured Duma Suspects to force them to bring false testimony against themselves. Maybe Abu Khdeir's "killers" sentenced to life imprisonment are also based on lies and falsehoods? Tzedek Tzedek Tirdof Parshat Mishpatim


Exodus 20:13
ֹלא תַעֲנֶה בְרעֲָך עֵד שָקֶר

“You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.”

Bringing false testimony is one of the violations of the 10 commandments.

Torturing someone to bring false testimony against himself is surely compounding the sin multiple times!

False confession revealed in Duma arson case. 

Amiram Ben Uliel emphasized that he only made the confession so that they would stop torturing him.
Duma torture testimony revealed. Documents from Deputy Attorney General's visit exposed for first time, revealing he 'silenced' detailed testimony of severe torture. Ben Uliel, the only suspect to have an indictment filed against him after he made a confession following intense torture, said that before his confession he was forced to lie backwards in a painful bridge position for many long minutes.
Elisha Odess 18 gave false confession of a crime he did not commit because of torture as revealed in Duma arson case
Transcriptions of ISA interrogation show after AG gave torture permission, minor suspect confessed - but wasn't indicted.
These hilltop Jewish youth in Israel are being used as political scapegoats and pawns.

So now Shabak themselves admit that they are guilty of justice.  

I ask,  who will now take ISA and AG  to court for torturing, slandering and traumatizing innocent kids?????

One could argue ok so just have them release the suspects and forget about it.  Don't wash our dirty laundry in public. 

Obviously, torturing and traumatizing innocent people should not be conveniently forgotten.  In order to heal it is imperative for the victims that justice be served. It is equally important for the perpetrators to be held accountable so that this kind of miscarriage of justice is not repeated!  

If Shabak behaved in such a cruel,despicable unlawful, illegal way to force suspects to confess to crimes that they did not commit, under the legal umbrella and sanction of the Attorney General of Israeli court system,  we can logically assume that they have done so other times. 

They have lost credibility and all their indictments are suspect.   

This brings me to another case recently in the News.

Abu Khdeir's killers sentenced to life imprisonment, 21 years
Feb. 4, 2016

Here is some background re: the Abu Khdeir murder.

Kidnapping and murder of Mohammed Abu Khdeir in Wikipedia

Several bystanders saw the kidnapping, and chased the car before notifying the father.[5] The family notified the Israeli police immediately afterwards at 4:05 am about the incident, and the police, accused by the family of neglecting their complaints,[47] tracked Abu Khdeir's cell phone, which was later retrieved from one of the arrested suspect's home,[48] and discovered his scorched body within an hour in the Jerusalem Forest.[5] According to the Palestinian Attorney General, Dr. Muhammed Abed al-Ghani al-Aweiwi, an autopsy conducted at the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute in Tel Aviv revealed that the child had soot in his lungs, indicating that he was alive and breathing when he was torched. He had been forced to swallow petrol beforehand.[49][50][51][52] The burns affected 90% of his body and it appeared he had sustained head injuries from a beating and was repeatedly hit in the head with a sharp object,[7][16][53] which was alleged to have been a tire iron,[54] but is now alleged to have been a wrench (see #Investigation of the crime). The Israeli Police suspected that the same vehicle was used in both Abu-Khdeir's and Zalum's cases.[28][55][56]According to the confession of the leading suspect, Yosef Haim Ben-David, 29, owner of an eyewear shop in Jerusalem,[2] and resident of the settlement of Geva Binyamin, the original intention was to beat up an Arab or torch a shop. They switched into civilian clothes after removing their religious clothes,[2] and almost cancelled the project when, on stopping to dine, the Arab proprietor reminded them as they left to pick up their change. On sighting Mohammed Abu Khdeir, they asked for directions to Tel Aviv, and he gave a rough indication, in poor Hebrew.[2] As he began to dial his cellphone, perhaps suspicious, the minors clamped hands over his mouth and dragged him into the car where, after he yelled "Allahu Akhbar" he was choked, and the ringleader gave instructions he be finished off. On arriving at the forest, he was beaten repeatedly with a crowbar, each blow accompanied by a recital of Jewish victims of terrorism: "This is for the Fogel family, and this is for Shalhevet Pass". They then poured gasoline over him, set him alight, and got rid of the evidence. The indictment against him and the two minors also includes an attempt to kidnap the 7-year-old Beit Hanoun boy, Moussa Zaloum, whom they choked and whose mother they punched in the face, and the torching of an Arab store earlier in June in the Palestinian village of Hizma.[2]

The  three prime suspects in the killing of Palestinian teenager Muhammed .Abu Khdeir have confessed to the crime and reenacted it, police said on Monday. by Stuart Winer July 7, 2014

I  do not rejoice at the death of innocent people when they are Arab. I also find abhorrent, false accusations and indictments of Jew or non Jew, Arab or Christian alike. I am interested in truth and justice. Precisely because I try to fear G-d, There is something called Universal Morality that applies to every being on this planet.  I know that there is a Heavenly Court that will judge us. Setting up Courts is one of the 7 Noahide laws.  Jews believe that G-d loves all of his creatures and wants justice for all. We pray for justice, and not only for Jews and not only for hilltop youth but for humanity. 

The Abu Khdeir prosecution and convictions smell like a skunk.  I can't buy the story.

Why am I bothering to bring up their case? As explained above, it bothers me when any individual is falsely maligned, falsely accused,  convicted or punished for a crime that they were not guilty of. In addition, I see here a pattern of political manipulations of the justice system in Israel in order to conveniently aid a broader agenda using these youth as scapegoats and pawns. 

In this saga, there were many disturbing elements.  Why would Jewish kids randomly burn a gay Arab kid in response to the murder of Gilad , Ayal and Naftali, Shalhevet Pass, and the Fogel family and in such a brutal manner that you need to be an Arab to even think of it.  Amazingly according to the report above they were indicted for other similar kidnappings and torchings.  These weren't religious hilltop youth but rather Soccer fans.  They apparently were troubled youth under surveillance.  I don't even think they lived in Judea and Samaria.  The 31 yr old who supposedly masterminded this fatal arson, of igniting a live person,  was allegedly an emotional unstable individual who had previously tried to murder his own child.  Someone was from Adam somewhere in Judea and Samaria. Vulnerable individuals basically. 

It was reported that Abu Khdeir, a 16-year-old from Shuafat in northeastern Jerusalem, was abducted, burned and brutally murdered on July 2, 2014, while waiting to enter a mosque .

Netanyahu and the others couldn't apologize for this "Jewish Terror" fast enough. 

Of course this was all alleged with no trial and Netanyahu et all were apologizing?   Was the eventual  trial transparent or was it held secretly by a kangaroo court?

Now that we know that Shabak fabricates scenarios to suit the agenda of the day, let me attempt to reenact what might have really happened in the Abu Khdeir case.  

The Arab gay kid was set on fire by other Arabs because they don't like Arabs being on the female end of a relationship. They have no problem with raping and sodomizing little Arab boys but when a boy grows up they need to act like a man and do it to other boys and not be on the receiving end themselves.  That is the prevalent culture of their society from what I understand.  Of course I might be totally mistaken on this and this is all conjecture.  Then they needed some way to put the blame on someone.  In addition Shabak under the jurisdiction of the Israeli government needed to somehow relieve the pressures upon them from the Obama Administration and the UN and the EU who were dangling hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars of all kind of goodies that is necessary for Israel's security.  All they needed was to come up with some evidence that Jewish terror exists among Jewish kids.  This evidence was extremely important because the 2 State Solution is built on the premise that we have two civilized political societies with which peace can be established.  If you only have one civilized society and the other is clearly an uncivilized brutal society, the foundation of the 2 State Solution dream will collapse like the Hamas tunnels.  Since the terror attacks on Israeli civilians was not something one could hide, the second best option to balance the scale of the two societies was to somehow show that neither were perfectly civilized.

This is the background from which this happened.  So Shabak together with their agents thought of these troubled individuals, Good and vulnerable scapegoats. Maybe they had substance abuse problems and other issues that were not being addressed.  Perhaps they were intoxicated at the time. Get them somehow involved, frame them and then have them confess to this crime.  Immediately apologize publicly profusely for the terrible crime committed by these Jewish kids.  Try to get as many right wing leaders and Rabbi's and political leaders in Judea and Samaria to hop on board, apologize and dangle a couple of goodies for influential positions for the politicians and projects that the settlements need in return for their self righteous condemnations.

The entire international press then will report on the phenomenon of "Violent angry Jewish Terrorists".  Viola, and that is what happened. The goal was reached and you can continue to talk about the 2 STate Solution in the UN and the EU and on this foundation the entire world will be able to condemn Israel with Israel being the useful idiot that allowed themselves to be had.

So now the kids must be indicted. Since the goal was reached, and Jewish terrorists were produced for International consumption,  the Shabak was going to go easy on these kids.  15 years or less with an apology.  But what happened next?  Israel was suddenly hit with an onslaught of terror attacks on its civilian and military population and the perpetrators were teenie boppers  - Arabs, 13 year olds, 15 year olds etc.  Almost nobody older than 19.  Uh OH!  How do you deal with this?  Israel must show its people that they will be tough against these minors.  But they are very much afraid that the organizations for the rights of children, especially Arab children, will be on their case for harsh punitive sentences.  

They now they came up with a solution. They decided to give life imprisonment to these troubled minors, these Jewish kids who confessed to burning the Arab kid Abu Khdeir, a crime that they are not guilty of but nevertheless confessed under torture,  and thereby Israel shows their critics that they are fair and non-biased against the Arab children who happen to be minors who knifed and murdered Jewish civilians. 

For those of us who remain passive in this charade of justice, Rabbis who don't want to get involved and turn their cheek, we learn for this weeks Parsha the teaching of Perek HaKones. One is liable in a Heavenly Court, in the case of Grama, indirectly causing a mistaken judgement, due to ones action or inaction, like not testifying.  One is Chayav Bedei Shamayim, guilty in a Heavenly Court, in the case of one who murdered intentionally without any witnesses. He can not be convicted in a human court of law but he will receive justice from a Heavenly Court.  His punishment, a death sentence will be executed by someone accidentally causing his death. Being judged by a Heavenly Court will happen as well to those who allowed a miscarriage of justice by being passive and not testifying. 

Do we really collectively want to be judged in a Heavenly Court for the unjust imprisonment, slander, torture and trauma of these youths?   If not then SPEAK UP!


Robin Ticker

Israel Advocacy Calendar (
Activist emails sent to my list  are L'Ilui Nishmat Yisrael ben David Aryeh ob"m (Izzy - Kaplan) and Howard Chaim Grief great activists and lovers of Eretz Yisroel, Am Yisroel and the Torah. Yehi Zichronum Baruch.  May their memories serve as a blessing. 

Most of these emails are posted on

Personal emails to individuals will not be posted to my blog. 
Post a Comment