A Warrior in Lebanon Shares his Pain "How is it Possible that We Win, Conquer the Territory and in the End Give it Back to the Enemy Every Time"?

Bsd

אל המקום אשר...

"עצוב כמה שזה נכון. לוחם משתף הכאב. "אך יתכן שאנחנו מנצחים, כובשים שטח ובסוף מחזירים אותו לאויבכל פעם מחדש"

So Sad how true it is. A warrior stationed in Lebanon shares his pain. "How is it possible that we win, conquer the territory and in the end give it back to the enemy every time."

https://www.facebook.com/share/r/1DXnVFigZV/ (h)

Basic translation 

This Warrior Chayal,  (IDF Soldier), is speaking from South Lebanon in 2026. 

He says that he was speaking from territory which was already conquered in 1985.

In 2000 Israel gave it back to the enemy in exchange for an illusive peace, for deceptive calm.

In 2006 Israel returned and reconquered the territory... just to end the war and then return the territory to the enemy in exchange for "peace".

In 2023 Again things exploded in our face.

In 2024 We were called to reconquer and when Hezbollah ran away we gave the territory back only so they can rearm...

In 2026 We are back and again they call me again to reconquer the territory and I am asking. What will be? Will we give it back to them again? What army acts like this? What country in the world acts like this? Will Ukraine capture territory and give it back to Russia? 

Israel gives it back and then needs to fight again and again to reconquer. 

We know Chayalim who have died here. We gather strength and fight and Conquer only to give it back to the enemy? For what? For a terror group that wants to humiliate us? There is no reason to build a wall to protect our communities only to have to conquer the territory again and again. 

To anyone that is "horrified" by the term "Conquer" כיבוש, This is what Ben Gurion did in 1948 and Rabin in 1967. Where is the idea that one conquers an area only to return it to an enemy that will go to war with you again? I am not willing to do this anymore!

-----

After listening to this Chayal share some painful truths it hit home even more when I watched the young daughter of a great Warrior Harel Birrenstock ob"m, killed in Lebanon this passed month August 2926, singing with longing for her father. 

In Tribute to Harel Birrenstock ob"m. Moving to Tears: Killed in Lebanon One Month Ago. His Daughter Ori sings to him out of Deep Longing for the Father he was.

https://shemittahrediscovered.blogspot.com/2026/09/in-tribute-to-harel-birnstock-obm.html?m=1

Was his untimely death really necessary? Why does Israel give back what they have conquered only to go to war again and lose more precious souls for no purpose? See how many family members are in deep loss... Our heart cries out for them in pain...May Hashem comfort them among the the mourners of Zion but may his ultimate sacrifice serve to revolutionize the Military strategy to be one that Conquers, Expels and Settles rather than Conquers and then gives the territory it conquered back to the enemy with some "peace deal" and then needs to reConquer and sustain painful losses only to give the territory it conquered back to the enemy once again, a non ending cycle of wasted sacrifice.

Enough is enough. Enough crying. Time to demand a change in military strategy that is dictated by politics and finally be victorious and fight to win. Victory and Winning translates to 

- Conquer, 

- Expel and 

- Annex 

Rather than be a puppet to outside, powerful, political forces.

Ein Od Milvado. 

Israel Trusts in G-d and in His Salvation Bzh!!! 

Am Yisrael Chai!